
In Parts 21 (Return) and 22 (Response) of Spiorad Àird nam Murchan, I explored how going back, physically and imaginatively, to places that hold meaning sparks a renewed answering in images and words. “Return” was about the act of going back; “Response” examined the ways the land, sea and community draw an answer from us. This new chapter; Reflection (Smaoineachadh)—completes and recommences that cycle. Reflection is the quiet hinge between returning and responding: the deliberate pause in which we look at what has been made and lived, understand it more deeply, and allow that understanding to feed forward into new questions, directions and forms.
While many rightly use the year’s turning as a vantage point for reflection, I’ve come to see it as continual and iterative: a practice embedded in the daily and seasonal rhythms of working on long-form projects. In Spiorad Àird nam Murchan, the western edge of the peninsula has taught me to slow down, to breathe, to let the work ripen, and to trust that the cycle is not linear but circular: return → respond → reflect → return. That circularity is geological and cultural here; it is inscribed in ring-dykes and sea-loops, in crofting seasons and community memory. It is, too, a creative method. (For the geological backdrop to this “ring,” see the Ardnamurchan ring complex / Great Eucrite discussions: Geological Society; JNCC site account.)

By reflection I mean an intentional pause to look back at work made (and the circumstances of making), to synthesise patterns and tensions, and to discern what to carry forward. It is more than editing; it is a form of situated thinking that integrates process notes, contact sheets, field recordings, sequences, reader/viewer feedback, and lived experience in the place itself.
From a linguistic angle, smaoineachadh (Scottish Gaelic) captures “thinking, reflecting, considering.” The verb smaoinich (“think/reflect”) derives from Old Irish smúainid, and its verbal noun smaoineachadh names the practice I’m describing: inquiring attentively, then proceeding (or pausing) with care.
Reflection is integral to any creative life because it:

My practice is rooted in the far west of Ardnamurchan; Sanna sands, Achosnich, Portuairk, the road past Kilchoan and out to the Lighthouse. The land’s volcanic architecture…. the famous Paleocene complex and the debated “ring-dyke”/lopolith form of the Great Eucrite is literally circular, reading like a natural amphitheatre around Glendrian and Achnaha. Standing there, you inhabit a ring of time. That morphology has influenced more than a few of my editorial choices: sequences that orbit, motifs that recur, pauses that feel tectonic rather than incidental.
For a succinct geologist’s walk-through, Lochaber Geopark and BGS/Earthwise guides situate the viewer within Centre 3’s concentric intrusions; the JNCC’s site account describes how the topography “accurately reflects” the intrusive arcs…. topography as trace of interior processes. Reflection, in that sense, is the reading of traces…. a practice that place itself models.
Culturally, Ardnamurchan holds an exceptionally long, layered human story; from Mesolithic shorelines and Neolithic cairns to Viking landfalls, the MacIains’ lordship, crofting, and the clearances. Resources like Heritage Ardnamurchan and the Ardnamurchan Transitions Project document that continuum and its sites (Greadal Fhinn, Swordle, Bourblaige). The archive of lived continuity and rupture encourages a slower relationship to time and therefore a reflective stance: you sense yourself as the latest custodian in a chain. For a living voice within that chain, Alasdair Maclean’s Night Falls on Ardnamurchan remains a touchstone…. intimate, attentive to crofting temporalities, and honest about return as both solace and struggle.
In short: the geology gives you circles; the history gives you cycles; the community gives you cadence. That triad makes reflection feel not like a luxury but like the only appropriate tempo.

Reflection tunes the work to the self and the self to the place. In practice:
The upshot is a more embodied sense of place…. not as backdrop, but as dialogic partner. Reflection is where that relationship is re-negotiated.

Plenty of thoughtful voices emphasise reflection as process, not postscript:
Taken together, they advocate iterative reflection; small, frequent passes that keep direction true and craft evolving.

Sustaining a long-form body of work hinges on reflection. In Spiorad Àird nam Murchan, reflection has:
Looking back to my earlier project “Dark Visions, I can see how reflective writing around each photograph, its making, its near-misses, its ethical questions….. expanded the project beyond aesthetic atmosphere into a pedagogy of process. Writing those pieces clarified themes and technical trajectories that I carry into Ardnamurchan work now (www.rkphotographic.com | Dark Visions Exhibition Introduction).
Reflection keeps long-form work honest. It asks: What belongs? What repeats without adding? What must be left for another time…. or another artist?

A canonical case for conceptual reflection is Alfred Stieglitz’s Equivalents (1920s–30s), the first sustained series to sever the photograph’s meaning from literal subject and to use the sky and clouds as emotional/metaphysical stand-ins. Stieglitz described them as “my philosophy of life”; photographs that are equivalent to inner states, not descriptions of cloud-shapes. The Art Institute of Chicago’s archive and The Met’s notes provide accessible context, and a technical history explains how orthochromatic emulsions once made skies difficult to render, increasing the deliberateness of his results.
Stieglitz’s habit of re-sequencing sets over time is itself a reflective practice; returning to earlier material to discover new alignments as his thinking shifted. Contemporary scholarship has even reframed the Equivalents against the era’s meteorology and aviation cultures, reminding us that reflection also sits in dialogue with science and technology.
Beyond Stieglitz, reflection operates as subject and method in many practices:
Reflection, then, is baked into both how photographs are made and what they can mean. Reflection is often a visual representation but importantly is as we discuss a practice to ground and feed into our work.

All long projects encounter lulls. Reflection converts those stretches from anxiety to incubation:
Seth Godin’s reminder that “the magic of the creative process is that there is no magic” frees these seasons from superstition; practice and thoughtful review are what carry you forward.

a) Journaling / field books
Keep a single, dated notebook for field days: weather, tide, lens choices, conversations, metaphors that surfaced. Short entries suffice; the aim is continuity. (Echoing Kleon: share small, share often…. privately first, publicly as appropriate.
b) Contact-sheet reviews
Print small thumbnails; mark instinctive “Yes/No/Maybe.” At sequence level, ask: What is this set about? Where does the eye rest? What repeats or jars?
c) Scrapbooks / digital pinboards
Pair own work with influences: croft fence beside a Stieglitz sky; latch beside archival crofting image; a line of Gaelic beside a geological diagram. Reflection thrives on adjacency.
d) Slow sequencing
Lay 30–40 6×4 prints on a table. Build three different sequences: (1) by time; (2) by motif; (3) by mood. Note what changes.
e) “Return lists”
After each review, capture 3–5 concrete “returns”: specific place + light + tide + season. This turns reflection into itinerary.
f) Community “scenius”
Trade works-in-progress with a small, trusted circle. Offer questions not prescriptions, and cite at least one strength and one opening. (Kleon’s scenius model is useful here.)
g) Ethical checkpoints
Keep a recurring checklist on consent, access, land care, and representation. Reflection isn’t only aesthetic; it’s relational and ethical.

Toponymy in the Gàidhealtachd skews strongly toward landform, water, colour, use and ecology. Elements explicitly meaning “to think/reflect” are rare in formal names; nonetheless, there are productive ways to connect Gaelic naming with reflection:
Within Lochaber/Ardnamurchan, the broader Gaelic lexicon around calm water / mirror-like surfaces can be suggestive in reading the land photographically:
Caveat & commitment: Where a direct semantic link to “thinking/reflecting” is not attested, I avoid forced etymologies. Instead, I use authoritative references (AÀA/STIT; Nicolaisen) and local signage/archives, cross-checked in LearnGaelic for lexical sense, to ensure interpretive captions remain accurate.

Rather than over-claiming specific “reflection” place-name elements, I look to Gaelic cultural practice; seanchas (oral tradition), proverbial wisdom, and narrative patience, as engines of reflective life. Scholarly overviews remind us that Insular Celtic traditions preserved by oral practice and later manuscript culture foregrounded deep time, seasonal cycles and the Otherworld…. structures that encourage reflective, non-linear storytelling.
Studies of folklore’s collection history (even if Ireland-focused) sharpen our awareness of the move from oral to written, and how reflection changes when stories are fixed on the page; that lens is useful when I decide what belongs in blog posts versus live readings as part of an exhibition or recorded soundwalks.
For local resonances, Maclean’s Night Falls on Ardnamurchan again stands out: it braids crofting journals with memoir; a reflective intergenerational dialogue grounded in this peninsula’s weather and work, not abstract theorising.
Sources and caution: I draw on general Celtic-Studies overviews to frame motifs, but remain careful not to flatten distinct Irish/Scottish contexts. Where Scottish Gaelic sources are thin in a given motif, I mark that explicitly and prioritise local testimony and archives over sweeping claims.

Reflecting across nine-ish years in Ardnamurchan has:

The geology offers a metaphor: intrusive rings that appear, are reinterpreted, and are returned to by each generation’s geologists. Even the Great Eucrite has been re-read from classic ring-dyke to a lopolithic, funnel-shaped body, an instructive example of scientific reflection revising earlier certainties. Our creative frameworks should be no less revisable.

I’d like to hear from other photographers, writers, painters, crofters, and walkers:
Consider experimenting this month with one reflective practice: a simple field journal; a weekly pinboard; a small table of 30 work prints you keep shuffling; or a three-person scenius who meet for one hour on Zoom to ask each other “What is this really about?” (Kleon).
If you prefer momentum to pausing, try Godin’s counsel: show up, ship something small, learn from it, then show up again…. reflection as the smallest meaningful loop.
I’ll continue to fold these reflections back into Spiorad Àird nam Murchan; to return, respond, and reflect within Ardnamurchan’s ring of stone, sea and story.

Geology & landscape
History, culture, community
Gaelic language, toponymy, hydronymy
Folklore & broader Celtic context (contextual)
Creative practice & reflection
Photography precedents—reflection as subject and method

Ainmean-Àite na h-Alba (AÀA) (2019–2024) Academic Papers [online]. Available at: https://www.ainmean-aite.scot/academic-papers/ (Accessed 3 January 2026).
Art Institute of Chicago (n.d.) The Alfred Stieglitz Collection: Equivalents [online]. Available at: https://archive.artic.edu/stieglitz/equivalents/ (Accessed 3 January 2026).
BGS / Earthwise (1996 reprint) Ardnamurchan – a guide to geological excursions [online]. Edinburgh Geological Society. Available at: https://earthwise.bgs.ac.uk/index.php/Ardnamurchan_%E2%80%93_a_guide_to_geological_excursions (Accessed 1 January 2026).
Brustein, D. (2020) ‘Seth Godin On Why Having A Consistent Practice Is The Birthplace Of Creativity’, darrah.co [online]. Available at: https://www.darrah.co/blog/birthplace-of-creativity (Accessed 2 January 2026).
Digital Photography School (n.d.) ‘10 Ways to Use the Beauty and Complexity of Reflections in Photography’ [online]. Available at: https://digital-photography-school.com/ways-to-use-reflections-in-photography/ (Accessed 3 January 2026).
Geological Society of London (n.d.) ‘Ardnamurchan Ring Complex’ [online]. Available at: https://www.geolsoc.org.uk/science-and-policy/100-great-geosites/landscape/ardnamurchan-ring-complex/ (Accessed 1 January 2026).
Heritage Ardnamurchan (n.d.) ‘History’ [online]. Available at: https://heritageardnamurchan.co.uk/history/ (Accessed 1 January 2026).
JNCC (n.d.) GCR site account 15: Centre 3, Ardnamurchan [PDF]. Available at: https://jncc.gov.uk/jncc-assets/GCR/gcr-site-account-15.pdf (Accessed 2 January 2026).
Kleon, A. (2014) Show Your Work! (secondary summaries cited: ThriveOps Labs; LinkedIn articles).
ThriveOps Labs (2024) ‘Show Your Work! by Austin Kleon’ [online]. Available at: https://www.thriveopslabs.com/knowledge/show-your-work-austin-kleon (Accessed 2 January 2026).
LinkedIn / Goel, A. (2024) ‘Key Takeaways from Show Your Work!’ [online]. Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/show-your-work-10-ways-share-creativity-get-discovered-anant-goel-zlgtc (Accessed 2 January 2026).
LearnGaelic (2021–2026) Dictionary and Reference [online]. Available at: https://learngaelic.scot/dictionary/ and https://www.learngaelic.net/reference/
LIoP (London Institute of Photography) (n.d.) ‘Photographers using reflection and portraits’ [online]. Available at: https://liop.co.uk/content-hub/photographers-using-reflection-and-portraits/ (Accessed 3 January 2026).
Maclean, A. (1984; 2022 reprint) Night Falls on Ardnamurchan: The Twilight of a Crofting Family. Edinburgh: Origin. Google Books entry: https://books.google.com/books/about/Night_Falls_on_Ardnamurchan.html?id=oC24EAAAQBAJ (Accessed 1 January 2026).
Markey, A. (2006) ‘The Discovery of Irish Folklore’, New Hibernia Review, 10(4), pp. 21–43. JSTOR: https://www.jstor.org/stable/20558106 (Accessed 3 January 2026).
Metropolitan Museum of Art (1927) ‘Alfred Stieglitz – Equivalent’ [object record online]. Available at: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/267451 (Accessed 1 January 2026).
Nicolaisen, W. F. H. (1960s; reprint) ‘The Semantic Structure of Scottish Hydronymy’, Scottish Studies [online PDF]. University of Edinburgh Open Journals: https://open.journals.ed.ac.uk/ScottishStudies/article/download/182/208/237 (Accessed 2 January 2026).
O’Driscoll, B., Troll, V. R., Reavy, R. J., & Turner, P. (2006) ‘The Great Eucrite intrusion of Ardnamurchan, Scotland: Reevaluating the ring-dike concept’, Geology, 34, 189–193. PDF: https://vrtroll.com/onewebmedia/The%20Great%20Eucrite%20intrusion%202006.pdf (Accessed 1 January 2026).
Robinson, K. (2009; 2015) (quotations as curated) The Element; Creative Schools.
— AZQuotes (curation) https://www.azquotes.com/author/22116-Ken_Robinson (Accessed 3 January 2026).
— BrainyQuote https://www.brainyquote.com/authors/ken-robinson-quotes (Accessed 3 January 2026).
Seth Godin (2020) The Practice: Shipping Creative Work.
— Seth’s Blog (resource page): https://seths.blog/thepractice/ (Accessed 3 January 2026).
— Brustein, D. (2020) Interview article cited above.
The Phoblographer (2021) ‘6 Photographers Get Creative with Reflections…’ [online]. Available at: https://www.thephoblographer.com/2021/09/10/6-photographers-get-creative-with-reflections-for-mind-blowing-results/ (Accessed 3 January 2026).
University of Leicester (n.d.) ‘Ardnamurchan Transitions Project’ [online]. Available at: https://le.ac.uk/archaeology/research/people-and-places/ardnamurchan-transitions (Accessed 1 January 2026).
Wild Ardnamurchan (n.d.) ‘Ardnamurchan Rocks | The Ardnamurchan Volcanoes’ [online]. Available at: https://www.wildardnamurchan.com/ardnamurchan-rocks/the-ardnamurchan-volcanoes (Accessed 2 January 2026).
Wiktionary (n.d.) ‘smaoinich’ [online]. Available at: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/smaoinich (Accessed 3 January 2026).
Wikipedia (overview) (n.d.) ‘Celtic mythology’ [online]. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celtic_mythology (Accessed 3 January 2026).